How we score

Every product on MushroomGrades gets a score from 0 to 100, built from six factors and applied the same way to every product. The score answers one question: how much real, well-made, clearly labelled mushroom are you getting for your money?

What the score measures, and what it does not

  • It measures what is in the product and how honestly it is labelled.
  • It does not measure whether a product improves your health. We do not make or score health claims.
  • No brand can pay for a better score. Affiliate links never change a score.
  • Missing information scores zero for that factor. A brand that hides something does not get the benefit of the doubt.

The six factors

FactorPointsWhat we check
Source20Is it the mushroom itself (fruiting body), or mycelium grown on grain? Grain stays in the powder and is mostly starch.
Extract type20Is it extracted, and does the label state the method and ratio? Reishi and chaga need a dual (water and alcohol) extract for full points.
Active compounds listed20Does the label list measured beta-glucans? A polysaccharide number alone scores low, because starch is also a polysaccharide.
Dose per serving15How much actual mushroom extract or powder is in the daily serving, using real milligrams, not “equivalent to” numbers.
Transparency and testing15Published lab results (COA), independent testing, heavy metal results, species testing, Latin name, and no proprietary blends.
Value10The price of a real dose (1,000 mg of extract or 3,000 mg of powder) compared with similar products.

Grades

GradeScoreMeaning
A85 to 100Excellent
B70 to 84Good
C55 to 69Fair
D40 to 54Poor
F0 to 39Avoid

Red flags

Some problems cap or reduce a score, whatever the other factors add up to:

  • A proprietary blend that hides the mushroom amounts caps the score at 54 (grade D).
  • No source stated and no beta-glucans listed caps the score at 39 (grade F).
  • Lab results that contradict the label, an active recall, or a regulator warning cap the score at 39.
  • “Mushroom” on the front when the product is only mycelium on grain, or disease claims, take off 5 points each.

Canada and the US

The score is the same in both countries. For Canadian products we also show the Natural Product Number (NPN) status from Health Canada separately, so US-only products are not penalised. When a brand sells different formulas in each country, we say which version we scored.

How we keep scores accurate

  • We score from the label, the brand’s published lab results and store listings. When we run our own lab tests, those results replace label claims.
  • A person checks every score against the label before it is published, including scores drafted with AI tools.
  • Every product shows the date it was last checked and the version scored. Products are rechecked at least every 6 months.
  • Brands can send corrections or lab results to partners@mushroomgrades.com. We change a score only for new evidence, never for payment.